MOURC Proceedings Archive - Pigeons, Doves Accepted
Duplicates
This is the 1981 to present Records Committee Proceedings archive for
The Loon, journal of the Minnesota Ornithologists' Union.
The last 2 years are available to MOU members.
Families
Whistling-Ducks, Geese, Swans, Ducks
New World Quail
Partridge, Pheasants, Grouse, Turkeys
Grebes
Pigeons, Doves
Cuckoos
Nightjars
Swifts
Hummingbirds
Rails, Gallinules, Coots
Limpkin
Cranes
Stilts, Avocets
Plovers
Sandpipers
Jaegers
Alcids
Gulls, Terns
Loons
Shearwaters and Petrels
Storks
Frigatebirds
Boobies and Gannets
Anhingas
Cormorants
Pelicans
Bitterns, Herons, Egrets, Night-Herons
Ibises
New World Vultures
Osprey
Kites, Accipiters, Hawks, Eagles
Barn Owls
Screech-Owls, Owls
Woodpeckers
Caracaras, Falcons
Flycatchers
Vireos
Shrikes
Jays, Nutcrackers, Magpies, Crows
Martins, Swallows
Kinglets
Silky-flycatchers
Nuthatches
Wrens
Thrashers, Mockingbirds
Dippers
Thrushes
Old World Flycatchers
Old World Sparrows
Pipits
Finches
Longspurs and Snow Buntings
Towhees, Sparrows
Yellow-breasted Chat
Blackbirds, Orioles
Warblers
Tanagers, Cardinals, Grosbeaks

Proceedings
Species: Pigeons, Doves
Passenger Pigeon
[Red-billed Pigeon]
Band-tailed Pigeon
Eurasian Collared-Dove
Inca Dove
Common Ground Dove
White-winged Dove

White-winged Dove (R) (Zenaida asiatica)Start Date 0000-00-00
RefFirstLastLocationCounty23CommentStatus
158:1461985-10-13DuluthSt. Louis(vote 10-0; The Loon 58:92-93). In the case of potential first state records , such as this , a vote of 10-0 is now required for acceptance: the seven regular Committee members plus the three alternate members vote. Accepted
avian
information
1985-10-13St. Louis10/13 St. Louis (first county record)
10/ 13 Lakewood Pumping Station, Duluth (I) P. Backstrom. First state record (see pages 92-92.)
58:92-931986indexMinnesota's First White-winged Dove
66:213-2141994indexMinnesota's Second White-winged Dove
267:451994-09-15DuluthSt. Louis(The Loon 66:213-214). Accepted
avian
information
1994-09-15St. Louis9/15 St. Louis (second county record)
Second state record, 9/15 Hawk Ridge Nature Reserve, St. Louis Co., FN et al (The Loon 66:213–214). The first state record was also during a migration census (Lakewood Pumping Station) in Duluth on 10/13/85.
71:1561998-04-21BloomingtonHennepin(record #98-42, vote 0-7). This dove was described as having a white “X-like pattern across the back” in flight and as being “an overall medium slate gray in color.” However, neither of these features is consistent with this species. In addition, the observers partly based their identification on it having a different “butterfly-like” flight, even though manner of flight is not a field mark in any of the larger pigeons/doves. It was unanimously agreed that a more accurate description is needed for such an unusual species to be accepted (it would have represented a third state record), and the opinion was advanced that this might have been a Rock Dove with white on the wings. Not Accepted
376:392003-07-05near Grand MaraisCook(record #2003-53, vote 7-0). All ten MOURC members vote on questions of whether or not photographs are identifiable. The identification of this third state record was unanimously Accepted, but by a vote of 3-7 the photos included with the documentation were judged not clear enough on their own to identify the bird. Accordingly, this species remains on the state list with the (s) qualifier (i.e., all the records are sight-only records, with none accompanied by an identifiable specimen, photo, or other physical evidence). Accepted
avian
information
2003-07-05Cook7/5 Cook (first county record)
Third state record 7/5 Cook (near Grand Marais) †JWH, CHo, †JWa (The Loon 76:47).
476:1522004-05-082004-05-15ElySt. Louis(record #2004-021, vote 7-0 on identification, vote 10-0 on physical evidence). All ten members vote on whether or not the identification can be made on the basis of physical evidence alone (in this case, photographs). The latter vote removes the “s” subscript from this species on the state checklist. Accepted
avian
information
2004-05-082004-06-16St. Louis5/8-6/16 St. Louis (third county record)
Fourth and fifth state records 5/8–15 St. Louis (Ely) ph. †SF, m.obs., 5/14 Olmsted (county road 9 marsh, near Rochester) JWH et al., ph. JJS.
576:1522004-05-14County Road 9 marsh near RochesterOlmsted(record #2004-022, vote 7-0. This record was documented only by recognizable photographs. Accepted
avian
information
2004-05-14Olmsted5/14 Olmsted (first county record)
Fourth and fifth state records 5/8–15 St. Louis (Ely) ph. †SF, m.obs., 5/14 Olmsted (county road 9 marsh, near Rochester) JWH et al., ph. JJS.
676:1522004-06-16Gnesen TownshipSt. Louis(record #2004-053, vote 7-0. Documented by a recognizable photograph, plus written details from two of the observers. Accepted
77:92004-07-31Otrey TownshipBig Stone(record #2004-081, vote 2-5). This bird was seen only briefly, and binoculars were not used. The description omitted color of bare parts, body color, and tail markings. Not Accepted
777:1692005-05-072005-05-08Empire TownshipDakota(record #2005-016, vote 7-0). Accepted
avian
information
2005-05-072005-05-08Dakota5/7-8 Dakota (first county record)
Seventh state record 5/7–8 Dakota (Empire Twp.) ph. BSe (The Loon 77:171).
878:402005-07-102005-07-16near Devil Track LakeCook(record #2005-046, vote 7-0). Photographed at a private residence northwest of Grand Marais. Accepted
avian
information
2005-07-102005-07-16Cook7/10-16 Cook (second county record)
Seventh state record and third consecutive summer occurrence: 7/10–16 Cook ph. †JGW, ph. †PHS, †PCC, m.ob (The Loon 78:54).
78:1262005-10-16near AppletonSwift(recirculated record #2006-020, first vote 4-3, second vote 3-4). Though contemporaneous field notes were submitted, the observer had no prior experience with this species. Documentation was submitted three months after the sighting. Not Accepted
78:542006indexAnother White-winged Dove in Cook County
978:1262006-05-102006-05-16MoraKanabec(record #2006-045, vote 7-0). Accepted
avian
information
2006-05-102006-05-16Kanabec5/10-16 Kanabec (first county record)
Ninth state record 5/10–16 Kanabec (Mora) †CAM, ph. DAC.
1078:1262006-06-022006-06-24Nelson's Resort at Crane LakeSt. Louis(record #2006-056, vote 7-0). Both of the above were photographed. Accepted
avian
information
2006-06-022006-06-24St. Louis6/2-24 St. Louis (fourth county record)
Tenth state record, fifth county record, and fourth consecutive summer record: 6/2–24 St. Louis (Nelson's Resort, Crane Lake) ph. JBP, ph. DMK.
79:592007indexWhite-winged Dove in Kanabec County
1179:1232007-05-042007-05-22LancasterKittson(record #2007-021, vote 7-0). Eleventh state record and ninth occurrence since 2003. Photographed. Accepted
avian
information
2007-05-042007-05-13Kittson5/4, 5, 13 Kittson (first county record)
Eleventh state record 5/4–22 Kittson (Lancaster) ph. LW, †JMJ, †PHS.
1280:52007-10-152007-10-21~10 miles north of Fergus FallsOtter Tail(record #2007-082, vote 7-0). Accepted
avian
information
2007-10-152007-10-21Otter Tail10/15-21 Otter Tail (first county record)
Two reports, both first county records: 10/15–21 Otter Tail (northeast of Elizabeth) MSa, ph. †DTT, †JMJ, m.ob., 11/20–21 Lake (Fernberg Trail) ph. fide BET.
1380:52007-11-202007-11-21~16 miles east of ElyLake(record #2007-087, vote 7-0). All but two of the state's thirteen records have occurred since 2003. Both of the above were photographed. Accepted
avian
information
2007-11-202007-11-21Lake11/20-21 Lake (first county record)
Two reports, both first county records: 10/15–21 Otter Tail (northeast of Elizabeth) MSa, ph. †DTT, †JMJ, m.ob., 11/20–21 Lake (Fernberg Trail) ph. fide BET.
1480:1152008-04-162008-04-22LutsenCook(record #2008-017, vote 7-0). Accepted
avian
information
2008-04-162008-04-22Cook4/16-22 Cook (third county record)
One bird present and photographed 4/16–22 Cook at a private residence near Lutsen fide JWL. This is the third record of this Accidental species in this county within the last six years.
1580:1152008-06-15Grand PortageCook(record #2008-033, vote 7-0). The 14th and 15th state records. Both were identifiably photographed. Accepted
avian
information
2008-06-15Cook6/15 Cook (fourth county record)
Fifteenth state record 6/15 Cook (Grand Portage) SSm, DCo, ph. SVe.
1682:32009-08-2454th Avenue East, DuluthSt. Louis(record #2009-050, vote 7-0). Accepted
avian
information
2009-08-242009-10-10St. Louis8/24, 10/4-10 St. Louis (fifth county record)
Two reports from St. Louis: 8/24 (54th Ave. E. and Superior St., Duluth) †CRu, 10/4–10 (40th Ave. W./Erie Pier, Duluth) CRu, ph. †PHS, †DOK, ph. †JPM, m.ob. (The Loon 82:94).
1782:32009-10-042009-10-1040th Avenue West / Erie Pier area, DuluthSt. Louis(record #2009-043, vote 7-0). All but two of the state's seventeen Whitewinged Doves have been found since 2003. The October bird was photographed. Accepted
1882:1032009-12-102009-12-23BurnsvilleDakota(record #2009-066, vote 7-0). Second county record. Photographed. Accepted
avian
information
2009-12-102009-12-23Dakota12/10-20, 21, 23 Dakota (second county record)
First state winter record, present at a private residence 12/10–23 Dakota (Burnsville) WJW, ph. KEO, ph. †CMB, ph. †DAC, †DWK, †DAB, m.ob. Second county record.
1982:1032010-04-152010-04-16WaconiaCarver(record #2010-008, vote 7-0). First county record. Photographed. Accepted
avian
information
2010-04-152010-04-16Carver4/15-16 Carver (first county record)
Two reports: 4/15–16 Carver (Waconia) ph. †FPe, 5/28–31 Lac qui Parle (Big Stone N.W.R.) †HHD, ph. BJU.
2082:1032010-05-282010-05-31Big Stone National Wildlife Refuge Auto TourLac qui Parle(record #2010-019, vote 7-0). First county record. All but 2 of the state's 20 records have occurred since 2003. Accepted
avian
information
2010-05-282010-05-31Lac qui Parle5/28-31 Lac qui Parle (first county record)
Two reports: 4/15–16 Carver (Waconia) ph. †FPe, 5/28–31 Lac qui Parle (Big Stone N.W.R.) †HHD, ph. BJU.
2184:32011-06-142011-06-19south of MillvilleWabasha(record #2011-029, vote 7-0). Photograph taken 18 June 2011 is diagnostic. First county record. Accepted
avian
information
2011-06-18Wabasha6/18 Wabasha (first county record)
Reported 6/14–19 Wabasha (S. of Millville) ph. GMi.
2284:1072012-04-212012-04-29LewistonWinona(record #2012-011, vote 7-0). The record was conclusively documented by written description and excellent photos. First county record. Accepted
avian
information
2012-04-212012-04-23Winona4/21, 22, 23 Winona (first county record)
One bird found 4/21–29 Winona (Lewiston) HHD, ph. †ANy, m.ob.
2384:1072012-06-172012-06-22La PrairieItasca(record #2012-018, vote 7-0). The high-quality photo was diagnostic. First county record. This species has now been recorded every year since 2003. Accepted
avian
information
2012-06-172012-06-22Itasca6/17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22 Itasca (first county record)
Observed 6/17–22 Itasca (feeder in La Prairie) ph. SC, m.ob.
2485:32012-11-09Taconite HarborCook(record #2012-039, vote 7-0). First fall record for Cook County. Predictably, this Casual species will be relegated to Regular status when the next Checklist of The Birds of Minnesota is updated in 2014. Contemporaneous field notes would have been helpful, but MOURC members thought the description was adequate. The experience of the observer with this particular species weighed significantly in favor of acceptance. Accepted
avian
information
2012-11-09Cook11/9 Cook (fifth county record)
One bird observed 11/9 Cook (Taconite Harbor) †PLJ.
2586:1072014-05-25Two HarborsLake(record #2014-025, Casual, vote 7-0). Adult, photographed. First spring record for the county. Accepted
avian
information
2014-05-25Lake5/25 Lake (second county record)
A second record for Lake was found in Two Harbors on 5/25 ph. †JWL, ph. †PHS, m.ob. Several days later another individual provided a first record for Grant (Elbow Lake) 5/30–31 ph. †CNn, †RSF.
2686:1072014-05-302014-05-31near Elbow LakeGrant(record #2014-030, Casual, vote 7-0). Adult, photographed. First county record. Accepted
avian
information
2014-05-302014-05-31Grant5/30-31 Grant (first county record)
A second record for Lake was found in Two Harbors on 5/25 ph. †JWL, ph. †PHS, m.ob. Several days later another individual provided a first record for Grant (Elbow Lake) 5/30–31 ph. †CNn, †RSF.
2787:42014-08-17WillmarKandiyohi(record #2014-040, vote 6-1). Adult. First county record. One dissenting member thought that while the identification of this bird was possibly correct, the description lacked several significant details, commenting that “there is nothing here about overall body color, blackish primaries and secondaries, and lack of dark spotting on the lower back/wings while at rest.” Accepted
avian
information
2014-08-17Kandiyohi8/17 Kandiyohi (first county record)
Only report 8/17 Kandiyohi †JoS.
avian
information
2015-04-252015-05-01Becker4/25, 5/1 Becker (first county record)
One report 4/25–5/1 Becker (Detroit Lakes) ph. NaH, †BAB, m.ob.
2887:952015-06-092015-07-06Eagle's Nest TownshipSt. Louis(record #2015-018, vote 7-0). Adult, photographed. Accepted
2989:32016-11-232016-12-04private residence, RamseyAnoka(record #2016-046, vote 7-0). Photographed, first county record. Accepted
avian
information
2016-11-232016-11-29Anoka11/23-29 Anoka (first county record)
The first fall report of this casual species since 2014:11/23–12/4 Anoka (found at a private residence in Ramsey) MAJ, †DWK, †ASu, ph. GHo, ph. RZi, plus photographs from eight additional observers submitted via eBird.
avian
information
2016-12-022016-12-04Anoka12/2, 3, 4 Anoka (second county record)
One report (continuing from November): 12/2–4 Anoka (Ramsey) m.ob.
3089:872017-04-16private residence in MontgomeryLe Sueur(record #2017-032, vote 7-0). Photographed. First county record. The bird stayed for approximately one week although the observer was uncertain of the exact date it was last seen. Accepted
avian
information
2017-04-16Le Sueur4/16 Le Sueur (first county record)
Two first county records: 4/16 Le Sueur (present for about a week in Montgomery) ph. DHv, 5/12 Blue Earth (Lake Crystal) ph. RJA (The Loon 89:87–91).
3189:872017-05-12Lake CrystalBlue Earth(record #2017-007, vote 7-0). Photographed. First county record. Accepted
avian
information
2017-05-12Blue Earth5/12 Blue Earth (first county record)
Two first county records: 4/16 Le Sueur (present for about a week in Montgomery) ph. DHv, 5/12 Blue Earth (Lake Crystal) ph. RJA (The Loon 89:87–91).
3290:32017-07-28LaSalleWatonwan(record #2017-038, vote 7-0). Photo is diagnostic for this species. Accepted
avian
information
2017-07-28Watonwan7/28 Watonwan (first county record)
New county record 7/28 Watonwan (La Salle) ph. STa.
3390:832018-07-04RamseyAnoka(record #2018-030, vote 7-0). Adult, photographed. Accepted
avian
information
2018-07-04Anoka7/4 Anoka (third county record)
Found 7/4 Anoka (Ramsey) ph.† BoS.
avian
information
2019-04-232019-05-23Hennepin4/23, 5/22, 23 Hennepin (first county record)
All reports: 4/23 Hennepin (Minneapolis, Minnehaha neighborhood) ph. DdS, PBl, 5/17 Faribault (Blue Earth) ph. † BAy, ph. † KEm, m.ob., 5/19–25 Lake (max. 2, Two Harbors) † JWL, † EzH, IsH, 5/22–23 Hennepin (Minneapolis, Standish neighborhood, 1.67 miles NNE from the April location) ph. PSt, ph. † PEB, m.ob.
avian
information
2019-05-17Faribault5/17 Faribault (first county record)
All reports: 4/23 Hennepin (Minneapolis, Minnehaha neighborhood) ph. DdS, PBl, 5/17 Faribault (Blue Earth) ph. † BAy, ph. † KEm, m.ob., 5/19–25 Lake (max. 2, Two Harbors) † JWL, † EzH, IsH, 5/22–23 Hennepin (Minneapolis, Standish neighborhood, 1.67 miles NNE from the April location) ph. PSt, ph. † PEB, m.ob.
avian
information
2019-05-192019-05-25Lake5/19, 20, 25 Lake (third county record)
All reports: 4/23 Hennepin (Minneapolis, Minnehaha neighborhood) ph. DdS, PBl, 5/17 Faribault (Blue Earth) ph. † BAy, ph. † KEm, m.ob., 5/19–25 Lake (max. 2, Two Harbors) † JWL, † EzH, IsH, 5/22–23 Hennepin (Minneapolis, Standish neighborhood, 1.67 miles NNE from the April location) ph. PSt, ph. † PEB, m.ob.
avian
information
2020-04-062020-04-07Polk4/6, 7 Polk (first county record)
Two reports: 4/6–7 Polk (private residence, near Tympanuchus Prairie) ph. SJo, REn, RLF, 4/28–5/2 Blue Earth (1, private residence, Lake Crystal) RJA, ph. †ChH, ph. KEm.
avian
information
2020-04-282020-05-02Blue Earth4/28, 30, 5/2 Blue Earth (second county record)
Two reports: 4/6–7 Polk (private residence, near Tympanuchus Prairie) ph. SJo, REn, RLF, 4/28–5/2 Blue Earth (1, private residence, Lake Crystal) RJA, ph. †ChH, ph. KEm.
avian
information
2020-06-012020-06-04Rice6/1-4 Rice (first county record)
 Found 6/4 Rice (since 6/2 according to homeowner, city of Faribault) †DAB, RBJ, RBW, 6/12–15 Hennepin (27th Ave. S., Minneapolis) JHv, ph. PSt, m.ob. and first county records 6/15 Goodhue (Red Wing) †EBy, 7/2 Ramsey †LiH.
avian
information
2020-06-122020-06-15Hennepin6/12, 13, 14, 15 Hennepin (second county record)
 Found 6/4 Rice (since 6/2 according to homeowner, city of Faribault) †DAB, RBJ, RBW, 6/12–15 Hennepin (27th Ave. S., Minneapolis) JHv, ph. PSt, m.ob. and first county records 6/15 Goodhue (Red Wing) †EBy, 7/2 Ramsey †LiH.
avian
information
2020-06-15Goodhue6/15 Goodhue (first county record)
 Found 6/4 Rice (since 6/2 according to homeowner, city of Faribault) †DAB, RBJ, RBW, 6/12–15 Hennepin (27th Ave. S., Minneapolis) JHv, ph. PSt, m.ob. and first county records 6/15 Goodhue (Red Wing) †EBy, 7/2 Ramsey †LiH.
avian
information
2020-07-02Ramsey7/2 Ramsey (first county record)
 Found 6/4 Rice (since 6/2 according to homeowner, city of Faribault) †DAB, RBJ, RBW, 6/12–15 Hennepin (27th Ave. S., Minneapolis) JHv, ph. PSt, m.ob. and first county records 6/15 Goodhue (Red Wing) †EBy, 7/2 Ramsey †LiH.
avian
information
2021-04-11Faribault4/11 Faribault (second county record)
Second county record: 4/11 Faribault (1, Winnebago) LiH.
avian
information
2022-05-17St. Louis5/17 St. Louis
One north report 5/17 St. Louis (Peabody St., Duluth) ph. †PHS, JWL, m.ob.
avian
information
2023-05-112023-05-14Ramsey5/11, 12, 13, 14 Ramsey (second county record)
One south record 5/11–14 Ramsey (private residence, Little Canada) ph. MWS, ph. †NMe, ph. †KEm, m.ob.
avian
information
2023-06-08Blue Earth6/8 Blue Earth (third county record)
avian
information
2023-06-092023-06-17Koochiching6/9, 17 Koochiching (first county record)
avian
information
2023-06-12St. Louis6/12 St. Louis
 
 Rare migrant and summer visitant throughout.

Notes:

The information in the above table comes from several different sources. The count in column 1 indicates which of the sources is considered the primary source.
'Accepted' MOURC entries from The MOURC Proceedings
'Not Accepted' or 'Rejected' MOURC entry from The MOURC Proceedings
Accepted MOU records assembled by David Cahlander
Sighting records for ()
Avian information from the occurrence maps, in dark red, assembled by Robert Janssen. Seasonal report for the species/season published in The Loon or The Flicker has been added.
Information from The Loon index assembled by Anthony Hertzel and David Cahlander